The Short Answer
For most of Mass: hands folded in prayer. The Church's rulebook (the GIRM) is nearly silent on laity hand positions — but tradition, rubrics, and common sense fill in the rest.
Prescribed by rubrics
Traditional / implied
Optional / permitted
Not prescribed for laity
Moment by Moment
Traditional
›
The classical Catholic prayer posture: palms flat together, fingers pointing upward, right thumb crossed over left. Hold before the chest with elbows close to the body. This is the default whenever you are not doing something else specific. When kneeling, sitting, or standing — hands remain folded unless a specific gesture is called for.
Described in the Ceremonial of Bishops (no. 107) and long-standing Roman Rite tradition. The GIRM itself does not specify hand positions for the laity — meaning folded hands is the understood baseline. Adoremus Bulletin
Prescribed
›
Right hand touches forehead, then chest/sternum, then left shoulder, then right shoulder. Say: "In the name of the Father, and of the Son, and of the Holy Spirit. Amen." Also made at the Final Blessing — cross yourself as the priest says the words. The GIRM directs the whole assembly to make the Sign of the Cross with the priest at the beginning of Mass (§50).
GIRM §50. Also: when the priest says "May Almighty God have mercy on you" in the Penitential Act — bow and make the Sign of the Cross. USCCB — GIRM
Prescribed
›
Gently strike your chest (over the heart) with a closed right fist. Done twice during the Confiteor at "through my fault, through my fault, through my most grievous fault" — once at each "through my fault" and again at "most grievous fault." Also at each "have mercy on us" during the Agnus Dei. A gesture of contrition rooted in the parable of the tax collector (Luke 18:13).
Specified in the rubrics of the Roman Missal for the Confiteor and Agnus Dei. National Catholic Register — "Catholic Calisthenics"
Prescribed
›
When the deacon or priest announces "A reading from the holy Gospel according to N," use your right thumb to trace a small cross on your forehead, then your lips, then your chest. The meaning: may this Gospel be in my mind, on my lips, and in my heart. Then respond: "Glory to you, O Lord."
Indicated in the rubrics of the Roman Missal at the Gospel. Universal practice of the Roman Rite. Adoremus — Gestures and Postures
Prescribed
›
At the words "and by the Holy Spirit was incarnate of the Virgin Mary, and became man" — bow your head and upper body. On Christmas Day and the Annunciation (March 25), everyone genuflects on both knees instead. Hands remain folded throughout.
GIRM §137. USCCB — GIRM
Traditional
›
After the priest elevates the Host, and again after he elevates the Chalice — bow your head and say silently: "My Lord and my God" (John 20:28). Hands remain folded. You are already kneeling from after the Sanctus through the end of the Eucharistic Prayer in U.S. parishes.
A centuries-old devotional practice tied to St. Thomas's words in John 20:28. Commended by St. Peter Julian Eymard and long encouraged by the Church. NCRegister — "Catholic Calisthenics"
Prescribed
›
As you approach the Eucharistic minister, bow your head as a gesture of reverence before receiving. This is the U.S. adaptation of GIRM §160. Then respond "Amen" when the minister says "The Body of Christ." If receiving on the hand, place one hand over the other, palms up. If receiving on the tongue, open your mouth and extend your tongue. Both are valid.
GIRM §160, U.S. adaptation: "the communicant bows his or her head before the Sacrament as a gesture of reverence." USCCB — GIRM §160
Traditional
›
A small bow of the head at every mention of the name of Jesus during Mass — and also at the names of the Trinity when the Doxology is prayed. Rooted in Philippians 2:10: "at the name of Jesus every knee should bow." Mandated at the Second Council of Lyons (1274). A beautiful and largely forgotten practice ready for revival.
GIRM §275 directs a bow of the head at the names of Jesus, Mary, and the saint of the day. NCRegister — "Catholic Calisthenics"
The Orans Question
🤔 What about people praying with arms outstretched?
You've probably seen it — people at the Our Father with arms raised and palms open, like the priest. This is called the orans posture (Latin: orans, "praying"). Here's the honest answer about what the Church actually says.
Not Prescribed
›
What the rulebook says: The GIRM prescribes the orans posture ("with hands extended") 28 times — and every single instance is a direction for the priest only. The laity are never directed to use it. The only posture specified for the congregation during the Our Father is standing.
What the U.S. bishops decided: In adapting the GIRM for the United States, the bishops debated whether to allow the orans posture for the laity. The proposal failed to reach the required two-thirds majority and was dropped entirely. The result: "No position is prescribed for an assembly gesture during the Lord's Prayer" (U.S. Bishops' Committee on Divine Worship, 2003).
Why it matters: During Mass, the orans posture is a distinctly priestly gesture — it signifies the priest gathering the prayers of the people and presenting them to God. Laity using the same gesture during the same prayer creates a visual confusion about roles. It's not a condemnation of those who do it in good faith; most people simply weren't taught otherwise.
What to do instead: Fold your hands in prayer. Bow your head. These are the ancient, fitting postures of a Christian at prayer.
What the U.S. bishops decided: In adapting the GIRM for the United States, the bishops debated whether to allow the orans posture for the laity. The proposal failed to reach the required two-thirds majority and was dropped entirely. The result: "No position is prescribed for an assembly gesture during the Lord's Prayer" (U.S. Bishops' Committee on Divine Worship, 2003).
Why it matters: During Mass, the orans posture is a distinctly priestly gesture — it signifies the priest gathering the prayers of the people and presenting them to God. Laity using the same gesture during the same prayer creates a visual confusion about roles. It's not a condemnation of those who do it in good faith; most people simply weren't taught otherwise.
What to do instead: Fold your hands in prayer. Bow your head. These are the ancient, fitting postures of a Christian at prayer.
GIRM §43, §160, §237 · U.S. Bishops' Committee on Divine Worship (2003) · Adoremus Bulletin — "About That Orans Posture" · Catholic Answers · Diocese of Springfield, IL
Not Prescribed
›
Holding hands during the Our Father is not in the GIRM — it's neither prescribed nor forbidden. It is not a liturgical tradition but a modern innovation. The bishops chose not to address it one way or another in the U.S. adaptations. If you're comfortable with it in a family or familiar context, it won't get you in liturgical trouble. If you're not comfortable, simply fold your hands — no explanation needed.
U.S. Bishops' Committee on Divine Worship (2003): no position prescribed or proscribed. Diocese of Springfield, IL — "Hey Father"
Sources & Further Reading
1General Instruction of the Roman Missal (GIRM), 3rd Typical Edition (2002), U.S. adaptations (2003) — §43, §50, §137, §160, §275 · usccb.org
2U.S. Bishops' Committee on Divine Worship (2003): "No position is prescribed for an assembly gesture during the Lord's Prayer."
3Adoremus Bulletin — "About That Orans Posture" · adoremus.org
4Adoremus — "Gestures and Postures" · adoremus.org
5National Catholic Register — "Catholic Calisthenics" (Angelo Stagnaro) · ncregister.com
6Diocese of Springfield, IL — "Hey Father: What is the proper hand gesture during the Our Father?" (Fr. Dominic Vahling) · dio.org
7Catholic Answers Q&A — "Orans Posture at Mass" · catholic.com